The Legality of Criminal and Civil Asset Forfeiture in South Carolina
Asset forfeiture lets the government permanently take property tied to a crime, and in most of the country, it can do so without ever convicting the owner. That gap between punishment and proof drives nearly every legal challenge to the practice. In 2023 alone, 45 states collected nearly $300 million through forfeiture, and the federal government collected $4.5 billion, according to the Institute for Justice’s Policing for Profit. Gerhard, R., & Gerhard, R. (2026, October 20). Policing for Profit 4. Institute for Justice.
Civil v. Criminal Forfeiture and the Federal Framework
The difference between Civil and Criminal asset forfeiture is who is on trial. Criminal forfeiture is an action against a criminal defendant, imposed as part of the sentence after a conviction. Civil forfeiture is an action against the property itself, which is why the cases carry captions like United States v. $35,000 in U.S. Currency. Because the property is the “defendant,” the owner’s guilt is legally beside the point.
In-Depth Criminal Forfeiture
Under...









